Butter chicken, murgh makhani, is the dish that converts people to Indian cooking: tandoori-style chicken folded into a tomato cream sauce so silky it barely seems legal. The restaurant version feels unattainable; it is not. Two stages, one pan, and the patience to let the sauce simmer properly, that is the entire mystery.
Stage one: the marinade does the heavy lifting
Cut 700g of boneless chicken thighs into large chunks and marinate in 150g plain yogurt with a tablespoon of grated ginger and garlic, a teaspoon each of garam masala, ground cumin and Kashmiri chili powder, half a teaspoon of turmeric, a squeeze of lemon and a good pinch of salt. One hour minimum, overnight for the real thing: yogurt tenderizes in a way nothing else does. Thighs, not breasts, they forgive and they flavor.
Char the chicken first
Restaurants use a tandoor; you use your broiler or a screaming-hot cast iron pan. Cook the marinated chicken in a single layer until it takes on real char at the edges, about 4 minutes a side under a hot broiler. It will finish cooking in the sauce, what you want here is smoke and color, the flavor that separates butter chicken from generic curry.
Stage two: the silky sauce
- Melt 3 tablespoons of butter and soften a finely diced onion until golden, about 8 minutes.
- Add a tablespoon of ginger-garlic paste, 2 teaspoons garam masala, a teaspoon of Kashmiri chili and a half teaspoon of ground fenugreek; bloom 60 seconds until fragrant.
- Add 400g crushed tomatoes and a teaspoon of sugar; simmer 15 minutes until deep brick red.
- Blend until completely smooth: this step is the silkiness, do not skip it.
- Return to the pan, stir in 150ml cream, add the charred chicken and simmer gently for 10 minutes.
- Finish with a knob of butter, a pinch of crushed kasuri methi (dried fenugreek leaves) and salt to taste.
Serving it right
A swirl of cream on top, scattered cilantro, and warm naan for the essential sauce-mopping, basmati rice alongside if you are feeding a crowd. The sauce is even better the next day, and it freezes beautifully, so doubling the batch is less a suggestion than a warning about how fast the first one disappears.
The two ingredients that matter most
Kashmiri chili powder gives the iconic color with gentle heat (paprika plus a pinch of cayenne substitutes in a pinch), and kasuri methi delivers the elusive restaurant aroma nothing else replicates: both keep for ages, and both are the difference between good and can’t-stop-eating.
Save this recipe for curry night, and simmer through more cozy recipes on Plumeo. Daily deliciousness at @Plumeoblog.